Digital Restoration of Battle of Cascina - Michelangelo

 

Battle of CascinaCopy of the Battle of cascina

 

Difference in center position

In Michelangelo's drawing, the person trying to put on clothes is placed in the center of the drawing. However, in Sangallo's picture, the center is around the head of "Soldier 8".
Furthermore in Michelangelo's drawing, the depiction on the left side of the center is complicated and dramatic, but in Sangallo's picture there are only four people drawn on the left side of the person wearing clothing and the spacing is sparse.

Michelangelo's drawing shows a movement like a series of swells seen in the Last Judgment later, but Sangallo's picture does not show such a big flow.

 

Battle of Cascina soldiers number① There are six people is common, (3,5,7,8,10,11).

② There is a possibility that 2, 1, 4 are not original of Michelangelo.

 


Soldiers number, Copy of Battle of Cascina    

 

 

Battle of Cascina digital restoration-2

Has the completed cartoon existed?

It is strange that duplicate paintings are not present other than Sangallo's copy despite the fact that Battle of Cascina is so famous painting.


 

What is Michelangelo's plan?

In the Battle of Cascina drawn by Sangallo, the figure of the enemy that attacks is not drawn.

As a result, the battle scenes drawn by Sangallo are lacking in tension.
It seems as if the subject which should be intense battle scene originally is as if it is a common the scene of the river play.

The movements of soldiers are also disjointed, there is no clear indication of the direction to try to escape from something, or to head towards something.

 

Plan of Battle of Cascina of Michelangelo

Clothes of soldiers hanging from trees

Enemy raid

 

Michelangelo may have planned to draw the figure of the enemy that attacks on the right side of the screen.

In that scene, a soldier who flees away, a soldier who is going to take a counterattack in a hurry, etc. must be drawn in a situation of great confusion.

And on the left side of the screen Michelangelo intended to draw a figure of a soldier who rushed into the clothes hanging from the tree.